User blog comment:Skittylover3/hi my name is skittylover/@comment-25990213-20151211175800/@comment-24947676-20151217175725

Did you even pay attention to Rebellion Story? During that wonderful little scene where Madoka braided Homura's hair, Homura asked Madoka something along the lines of the following; "I had a bad dream in which you had to go away forever, and then only I could remember you". And to that, Madoka responded something along the lines of "Silly Homura-chan! I'd never want to leave you behind!"

This implies that Madoka was not happy with being a Goddess.

Also, remember the translation I found of the concept movie? The "What is Happiness" part? Madoka and Homura talk about what happiness is. They say that Heaven (where Godoka resided) didn't have the bright sunbeams of May, a warm family, or sunny-side up eggs for breakfast. They also say that "the goddess" didn't have her name called by anyone (well, except Homura), she couldn't call someone's name, and didn't have anyone thinking about her except for Homura. If the rest of the What is Happiness talk is meant to semi-recap the ending of Rebellion, then this implies that Madoka never had true happiness when she became a Goddess!